FLOWERY BRANCH – Let’s call this a setting of expectations.

It would be uncharitable for anyone not to want Falcons quarterback Michael Penix Jr. to play his best Thursday night against the Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field as he returns from his third ACL tear.

“To see how far he’s come and the work he’s put in, to see his teammates, the other quarterbacks, support him and rally around him, very excited for Mike,” offensive coordinator Tommy Rees said Tuesday.

That said, it’s going to be really difficult for Penix to have the sort of performance he likely envisions. So much so that, if you suspect he has been ready to play all along and cherry-picked his return (I do not), he would be off his rocker to choose this one.

First, since suffering the injury in November, he hasn’t played in a game in 10 months. It would be almost impossible for Penix’s reentry to competition to not encounter some turbulence, either from rust and/or overeagerness.

Also, he’ll be playing his first snaps in a new offensive scheme with a new offensive coordinator. He has had practice time with coach Kevin Stefanski’s offense and has had plenty of time to meet with Rees, but it’s not the same as actually running those plays in a game. If it were the same, no NFL team would ever play starters in exhibition games.

How well Penix and Rees connect with each other could also be a challenge. Rees and Penix have worked together on the practice field and have had conversations about Penix’s playing preferences, and Penix spoke Tuesday of his trust in his coordinator.

However, there is no substitute for actual game experience to foster that bond.

“I think, you call plays for a quarterback for the first time, you try to build a rhythm and connection with him,” Rees said.

And, for that matter, Rees himself does not teem with experience. He is in his second season as an NFL offensive coordinator and his first full season as play caller. (He held the position last year in Cleveland with Stefanski and took over play-calling duties midway through the season.) Through two games this season, he has failed to guide the Falcons offense into the red zone.

It’s fair to say that quarterback Cooper Rush didn’t help matters. Regardless, the Falcons are the first team to not take a red-zone snap in its first two games since the 2008 St. Louis Rams.

“Not fun,” Rees said. “We’ve got to convert.”

Having limited preparation time for the Thursday night game doesn’t help, either. And it could be especially tricky against Green Bay.

First, Green Bay defensive coordinator Jonathan Gannon is new, meaning there isn’t much history to anticipate how he might deploy the Packers defense. On top of that, Gannon is more unpredictable than a lot of defensive coordinators.

“Green Bay does a really nice job mixing it up on defense,” Rees said. “If you watch their first game to the second game, it looks like two different groups in terms of how they prepare for opponents.”

The tactic has served to create a quarterback pressure rate (31.6%) that is tied for sixth in the NFL. That doesn’t bode well for an offensive line that could have done better with keeping the pocket clean for Rush in the Falcons’ first two games.

Also, Lambeau figures to be raucous, which means that communication may be difficult and that the Falcons could have to operate on a silent count. And, for whatever it’s worth, the Packers have won their past 13 home openers, which Thursday’s game will be. They’re tied for the NFL record.

In short, the Falcons don’t have much margin for error, and the circumstances are ripe for error.

The Falcons aren’t without hope. For one thing, Stefanski’s record in Thursday night games is a spotless 5-0. Rees can spring his own wrinkles on Gannon. And Penix’s return could give the team a lift.

“Thursday football is just about executing the game plan and who has more energy and juice, honestly,” veteran tight end Austin Hooper told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution Tuesday. “Who can physically recover to get into a car crash better than the other team.”

Penix can’t help with the second part but certainly could with the first.

“I’m excited to run the plays,“ Penix said. ”I really trust Tommy, Kev and AVP (quarterbacks coach Alex Van Pelt), (assistant quarterbacks coach) Jordan Reid in there, (passing game coordinator) Tanner (Engstrand), all those guys, to prepare our room to go out there and win football games.”

With so many variables tilting against Penix, the Falcons will need every advantage they can find.


You can now get my column sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for my newsletter here.

About the Author

Keep Reading

Atlanta Falcons quarterbacks Tua Tagovailoa (left) and Michael Penix Jr. watch from the sidelines Sunday. One of them might start Thursday night's game against the Green Bay Packers. (Miguel Martinez/AJC)

Credit: Miguel Martinez/AJC

Featured

Atlanta's City Council proposed a resolution urging the mayor's office to move forward with plans to construct light rail along the Eastside Beltline. (Courtesy of Atlanta Beltline Inc.)

Credit: Atlanta Beltline Inc.